50 Styles of American Pizza

America is all about innovation, while respecting tradition. The definition of pizza is: Flatbread with Condiments. Go to NewMexicanPizza.com to voice your opinion!

ALL AMERICAN PIZZA STYLESMARK STENSLAND FOUNDER OF NEW MEXICAN PIZZA LLC, AUTHOR OF THE NEW MEXICAN PIZZA DIETNEW MEXICAN PIZZANEW MEXICAN STYLE PIZZA

Mark Stensland

11/22/202612 min read

Every Style of Pizza in America

I was out on one of my long walks in Albuquerque listening to Nino Coniglio's The Pizza Podcast when a lightbulb switched on in my head—and honestly, my culinary imagination hasn't turned off since. Nino (world champion pizzaiolo and founder of Williamsburg Pizza) was talking with Dan Richer (chef-owner of Razza in Jersey City and co-author of The Joy of Pizza), and Richer dropped a line that stripped away every ounce of culinary snobbery in one breath: "Pizza is basically flatbread with condiments on top".

Hear me out on this. Once you stop treating pizza like some untouchable museum piece and start seeing it through a pizzaiolo lens—just a base (dough or batter), toppings, liquid sauces/drizzles, and dehydrated seasoning flakes—the combinations become infinite. Even if you eat three to six meals a day and have forty-five or fifty Christmases left in your lifetime (roughly 50,000 meals), you could never run out of fermented flatbreads and microbiome-supporting condiments waiting to be invented.

That's the whole heartbeat behind my book, The New Mexican Pizza Diet. Here in America, we don't just copy recipes; as Ken Forkish puts it in The Elements of Pizza, "As Americans, we distinguish ourselves with our variety, abundance, and freedom to experiment". And yet, when I dropped over $300 on Nathan Myhrvold and Francisco Migoya's massive three-volume tome Modernist Pizza, I noticed they didn't mention a single thing about New Mexican-style pizza. That lit a fire under me.

The New Mexican Pizza Diet allows you to Read Like a Creative Writer (This is how you beat AI)

When I set out to write The New Mexican Pizza Diet, I knew it had to be something AI--or anyone with AI-- could never write, let alone fathom.

AI can't invent new food stories—it doesn't have a sense of flavor, because it can't taste, smell, remember, or feel the terroir (the taste of a place) of where you live. You can. (Send your recipes to https://NewMexicanPizza.com.)

Before we dive in, a quick note on grammar: in American culture, people almost never attach state demonyms to food. Every time I bring up New Mexican Pizza, LLC or The New Mexican Pizza Diet, somebody tries to "correct" me and insist it should be New Mexico Pizza. (What are your thoughts on that? Why is it weird to refer to people living in a state by their demonym?) To push back against that reflex, I wrote this whole 50-state atlas using every state's demonym.

That said, this list has also bailed me out of countless awkward conversations– when someone tells me where they're from or where they've lived, and I have no idea what to say next. Grab a pocket notebook, think about how you'd eat these—maybe with Dan Pashman's Inside-Out Fold or "Travolta" double-stack, or Josh's "Batwing" and Nicole's "Crust-First" strategies from A Hotdog Is a Sandwich—and let's tour all 50 states of American pizza.

Alabama Through Iowa: White Sauce, Coal Ovens, and Tavern Squares

  • Alabamian Style Pizza: People argue plenty over what Alabama-style pizza actually is, but to me it has to at least feature Alabama White Sauce, which many sources trace back to Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q in Decatur around 1925. As Robert Moss writes in Southern Living, it's a silky, tangy mayonnaise-and-vinegar base with a heavy kick of black pepper, layered with lemon juice, Worcestershire, hot sauce, a touch of sugar, and sometimes mustard, horseradish, garlic, or onion powder—throw that over a BBQ chicken pizza and you're in business.

  • Alaskan Style Pizza: I couldn't find any food historians pointing to an official Alaskan-style pizza, so if it were up to me, I'd lean right into the state's wild-yeast sourdough heritage. Build a naturally leavened sourdough crust and top it with local game, smoked salmon, a cream sauce, and a dehydrated berry pizza flakes blend.

  • Arizonan Style Pizza: I'm not too sure there's a single official Arizona style either, so I'd channel the iconic Sonoran hot dog—bacon-wrapped, grilled, tucked into a soft bolillo roll, and loaded with pinto beans, grilled and fresh onions, mustard, mayo, jalapeño salsa, and tomatoes. Make a flatbread that mimics a bolillo roll, puree those flavors into a Southwestern sauce, and top it with sliced bacon sausage.

  • Arkansan Style Pizza: Arkansas is still carving out its signature pie, though Elizabeth L. Cline in the Arkansas Times makes a strong case for Little Rock's Pizza Cafe (opened in 1991). Founder Richard Harrison perfected a crisp, honey-infused dough trimmed with a thick braided crust and served with honey on the side for dipping.

  • Californian Style Pizza: In The Pizza Bible, World Pizza Champion Tony Gemignani's California chapter is a grain-lover's dream: Sprouted Wheat, Einkorn, Khorasan, and Multigrain doughs. He pairs them with Campari tomatoes (my personal favorite tomatoes!), three standout organic California cheeses—Cowgirl Creamery's buttery triple-cream Mt. Tam, Nicasio Valley Cheese Company's Nicasio Reserve, and a light Swiss-Italian style—plus eggplant, olives, fig, almond, and Monterey Jack.

  • Coloradan Style Pizza: Invented in 1973 by Beau Jo's Pizzeria, the Colorado mountain pie is a massive, heavily topped pizza framed by a hefty, hand-braided whole-wheat crust sweetened with local honey—and built specifically to be dipped in honey when you're done.

  • Connecticuter Style Pizza: New Haven apizza uses an extensively fermented, high-hydration dough baked in a coal-fired oven for an asymmetrical, chewy, deeply charred crust. Its crown jewel is the white clam pie popularized at Frank Pepe's in the 1960s, where, as Tony Gemignani notes, canned clams bake right on the pie while in-shell clams are steamed separately with olive oil, garlic, and wine and added post-bake so you never get raw or soggy spots.

  • Delawarean Style Pizza: Made famous along the coast by Grotto's Pizza since 1960, Delaware's boardwalk swirl lays down a blanket of white cheddar and mozzarella and tops it with a signature spiral of sweet, heavy tomato paste. As HuffPost puts it, it may not be gourmet, but it's pure beach-trip nostalgia—especially loaded up Baker's Choice style with pepperoni, mushrooms, sweet peppers, sausage, onion, garlic, and extra cheese tucked under that sauce swirl.

  • Floridian Style Pizza: Ian MacAllen (Red Sauce America) uncovered an intriguing twist: "Florida Style Pizza" actually has roots in Philadelphia as Inside-Out Pizza—deep-fried pockets of dough stuffed with cheese, sauce, and sometimes pepperoni. Down in Miami, though, you also get Floridian Cuban pizza: a thick, doughy deep-pan pie using a mozzarella-and-gouda blend with toppings baked right underneath the cheese matrix.

  • Georgian Style Pizza: The Atlanta hybrid crossbreeds New York gas-deck oven baking with a big, airy Neapolitan cornicione. All the more, since Georgia is famous for peaches, I'd drizzle it with a spicy peach BBQ sauce and hit it with dehydrated peach flakes.

  • Hawaiian Style Pizza: Even though pineapple-and-ham pizza was invented in Canada, Hawaii's prevailing local style favors thick, pan-baked crusts strong enough to carry heavy, sweet-and-savory island staples like Kalua pork.

  • Idahoan Style Pizza: Reflect local agricultural yields with the rustic potato-bacon pie—wood-fired or deck-baked with thinly mandolined potatoes, cream bases, and cured meats.

  • Illinoisan / Chicagoan Style Pizza: You have to admire Chicago's courage in inventing its own pizza grammar. Everyone knows towering deep-dish (a high-fat, biscuit-like pan crust with inverted cheese-under-sauce architecture), but cracker-thin, square-cut tavern style was actually the first Chicago style to hit the scene, originally served at neighborhood bars.

  • Indianian Style Pizza: Hoosier tavern style puts a local spin on the Midwestern square-cut pie with finely ground sausage and a heavily baked, crispy perimeter.

  • Iowan Style Pizza: Don't laugh—Iowa turned gas-station convenience-store breakfast pizza into a full-blown cultural phenomenon, loading a standard pan crust with cheese sauce, scrambled eggs, and breakfast meats.

Kansas Through New York: Blue-Steel Pans, Provel, and Hatch Green Chile

  • Kansan Style Pizza: Kansas City style pairs a flaky, medium-thick crust with smoked meats and slightly sweet, barbecue-influenced tomato sauces.

  • Kentuckian Style Pizza: The Bluegrass regional pie leans on regional chain traditions, combining a finely milled flour crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a dense layer of provolone.

  • Louisianian Style Pizza: Creole pizza takes traditional dough or a French bread base, seasons it heavily with Cajun spices, and piles on shrimp, crawfish, or muffuletta olive salad.

  • Mainer Style Pizza: The New England pan pie draws heavily on Greek-style techniques, baking in deep oiled pans so the outside fries crisp while the interior stays spongy and focaccia-like.

  • Marylander Style Pizza: Ledo style is strictly rectangular, built on a flaky, pastry-like crust topped with sweet tomato sauce and smoked provolone, traditionally cut into small squares.

  • Massachusettsan Style Pizza: South Shore bar pizza is a ten-inch pan-baked pie defined by its lacy, caramelized edge of burnt cheddar and tomato sauce fused right onto the walls of the pan.

  • Michigander Style Pizza: Detroit style bakes high-hydration dough in rectangular blue-steel automotive parts pans, delivering an edge-to-edge crispy cheese crown (frico) of Wisconsin brick cheese finished with parallel stripes of sauce applied after the bake.

  • Minnesotan Style Pizza: 'Sota style piles a staggering amount of toppings and mozzarella over the sauce on a thin crust, bakes it hard, and slices it into squares.

  • Mississippian Style Pizza: The Delta pan pie delivers thick-crusted Southern soul-food comfort, bringing local sausages together with a slightly sweeter tomato reduction.

  • Missourian Style Pizza: Made definitive by Imo's, St. Louis style uses an unleavened, cracker-thin crust cut into squares (because thin triangles would collapse under the toppings) and blankets it in Provel—a processed blend of cheddar, Swiss, and provolone that melts with zero stretch. In The Pizza Bible, Tony Gemignani pairs it with a slightly sweet oregano tomato sauce, sweet fennel sausage, natural-casing pepperoni, grated parmesan, and a drizzle of garlic oil.

  • Montanan Style Pizza: Much like Alaska's tradition, the Big Sky sourdough pie relies on robust, cold-fermented sourdough crusts tough enough to shoulder heavy, meat-forward toppings.

  • Nebraskan Style Pizza: Nebraska's hamburger pizza channels a cheeseburger straight onto a medium-thick crust using ground beef, pickles, cheddar, and mozzarella.

  • Nevadan Style Pizza: Las Vegas import style thrives on exact replicas of New York and Neapolitan legends—even importing specific flours and water mineral profiles to mimic East Coast and Italian bakes.

  • New Hampshirite Style Pizza: New England Greek style dominates here too, turning out a thick, oily shallow-pan crust with a distinct crunch and a heavily blended cheese profile.

  • New Jerseyan Style Pizza: The Trenton tomato pie is a minimalist masterpiece on a crisp, New York–adjacent crust where mozzarella goes down first—Tony Gemignani prefers sliced mozzarella for evenness so it stays creamy without browning—and heavily hand-crushed, boldly seasoned plum tomatoes go on top to intensify in the oven heat.

  • New Mexican Style Pizza: Out of every regional style in America, I genuinely believe New Mexico's culinary toolkit is the most fertile ground for innovation. Right now, green chile pizza is defined by our terroir—specifically the mandatory inclusion of roasted Hatch green chiles on a hand-tossed or pan crust. But given how deeply Native American, Mexican, and New Mexican foodways shape this region, what is a New Mexican pizza without heirloom corn-flour dusting, fermented green or red chile sauces, homemade kefir/A2 cheeses, and dehydrated green and red chile seasoning flakes? (That's the whole universe I unpack in The New Mexican Pizza Diet.)

  • New Yorker Style Pizza: Widely considered the gold standard of the American slice, New York style was the first to popularize large, foldable, moderate-hydration dough baked directly on a gas deck oven hearth and topped with low-moisture mozzarella.

North Carolina Through Wyoming: Cold Cheese, Trays, and the "Spokane Tuck"

  • North Carolinian Style Pizza: Carolina neo-artisan is a fast-growing wave of wood-fired pies pairing locally milled flours and Appalachian ingredients on a Neapolitan-style chassis.

  • North Dakotan Style Pizza: Upper Midwest tavern style trims back dough density in favor of a thin, crisp base loaded edge-to-edge with meat and heavy cheese, sliced into squares.

  • Ohioan Style Pizza: Ohio Valley style is gloriously unorthodox: they bake a square pie with tomato sauce alone, then immediately dump cold shredded provolone and raw pepperoni on top the second it leaves the oven so residual heat gently sweats the toppings.

  • Oklahoman Style Pizza: Tulsa style riffs on the Midwestern tavern pie with a heavily blistered thin crust, sweet sauce, and generous smoked provolone.

  • Oregonian Style Pizza: Portland artisanal style pushes California and Neapolitan traditions forward with long-fermented sourdoughs and an obsessive devotion to hyper-local, foraged Pacific Northwest ingredients.

  • Pennsylvanian Style Pizza: Old Forge style skips round pies entirely in favor of rectangular pan-baked "trays" and "cuts," featuring a light, airy crumb and a fiercely guarded proprietary cheese blend (often American and brick cheese).

  • Rhode Islander Style Pizza: Bakery pizza (pizza strips) is a room-temperature, focaccia-like rectangular crust slathered in thick, herbaceous tomato paste—with zero cheese.

  • South Carolinian Style Pizza: The Lowcountry pie treats dough as a vehicle for regional icons like pimento cheese, pulled pork, and coastal shellfish.

  • South Dakotan Style Pizza: Midwestern thin crust here uses a crisp, attenuated, commercially yeasted dough topped with herbaceous sauce and baked until the cheese achieves serious browning.

  • Tennessean Style Pizza: Memphis barbecue pizza swaps classic red sauce for a sweet-and-tangy barbecue reduction piled high with smoked pulled pork, cheddar, and mozzarella.

  • Texan Style Pizza: Texas hybrid style relies on a sturdy, large-format, slightly thicker oil-enriched dough engineered to support the sheer mechanical weight of Central Texas smoked brisket and jalapeños.

  • Utahn Style Pizza: The Pioneer pie is a mountain-west cousin featuring a thick, sweet crust often enriched with honey and milk powder to carry dense layers of cheese and meat.

  • Vermonter Style Pizza: The Green Mountain farm pie brings wood-fired craft together with local dairy—mixing sharp Vermont cheddars with mozzarella and occasionally finishing with a maple-syrup glaze.

  • Virginian Style Pizza: Deeply influenced by the D.C. metro area, the Mid-Atlantic oversized slice bridges the structural gap between foldable New York pies and thicker, sweeter pan crusts.

  • Washingtonian Style Pizza: Seattle sourdough showcases highly hydrated, naturally leavened crusts topped with regional seafood or cured meats—and if you fold the tip up until it touches the outer crust (cornicione), you just pulled off a "Spokane tuck".

  • West Virginian Style Pizza: Inspired by the state's famous coal-miner pepperoni roll, this pie uses a soft, enriched dough heavily saturated with the rendered paprika oils of densely packed pepperoni.

  • Wisconsinite Style Pizza: Milwaukee style is classic tavern-pie craft—a structurally brittle, cracker-thin crust cut into squares and elevated by unbeatable local Wisconsin mozzarella and cheddar.

  • Wyomingite Style Pizza: Frontier pan pizza reflects rugged Western appetites with a dense, high-calorie, thick-crust pie heavily fortified with meats and baked in cast-iron pans.

Sources, Links & Further Reading

Everything in this post comes straight from my own kitchen experiments, road-trip curiosity, and the research notes inside The New Mexican Pizza Diet. Click around, dig deeper, and exercise that creative muscle.

My Book & Community Hub

Clickable Web Articles, Podcasts & Videos

Books, Podcasts & Print Sources Referenced in This Essay

  • Ken Forkish, The Elements of Pizza (Ten Speed Press, 2016)

  • Nathan Myhrvold & Francisco Migoya, Modernist Pizza, vols. 1–2 (The Cooking Lab, 2021)

  • Tony Gemignani, The Pizza Bible (Ten Speed Press, 2014)

  • Dan Richer & Nino Coniglio, The Pizza Podcast

  • Peter Reinhart, American Pie: My Search for the Perfect Pizza (Ten Speed Press, 2003)

  • Liz Barrett, Pizza: A Slice of American History (Voyageur Press, 2014)

  • Carol Helstosky, Pizza: A Global History (Reaktion Books, 2008)

  • Steve Dolinsky, Pizza City, USA: 101 Reasons Why Chicago Is America's Greatest Pizza Town (Northwestern University Press, 2018)

  • Craig Whitson & Tore Gjesteland, Passion for Pizza (Agate Surrey, 2015)

  • Ed Levine, Pizza: A Slice of Heaven (Universe Publishing, 2005)

  • Marc Vetri & David Joachim, Mastering Pizza (Ten Speed Press, 2018)

  • "Casey's: New Breakfast Item," CSP Daily News (September 29, 2021)

  • "How Red's Savoy Took 'Sota Style from 'No Such Thing' to a Regional Phenomenon," PMQ Pizza Magazine (August 4, 2024)

Creative Workshop: Your Turn to Out-Create the Algorithm and beat AI!

Even if some states try to lock themselves into a single tradition, pizza is a canvas—and you have the freedom to build right on top of what's already there. Pick one of these 50 states, or grab two or three (where you're from, where your family grew up, or somewhere you're dying to visit) and mash them together into a brand-new pie.

Think beyond the standard round cheese pie, too. Experiment with long-fermented sourdough or heirloom corn masa doughs, craft a lacto-fermented sauce or drizzle, dehydrate your own state-inspired pizza flakes blend, or even break out of the circle with wild, out-of-the-box dough shapes. Bonus points if you make it genuinely good for your gut microbiome—ditching the ultra-processed junk, refined sugars, and synthetic seed oils so your kitchen turns into an alchemy lab instead of a fast-food factory.

Don't surrender your craft or your sense of flavor. Go invent your own spin on one or more of these American pizza styles—write down the story of how it tastes, smells, crunches, and hits your memory—and submit your creation to https://NewMexicanPizza.com. And if you want the full blueprint for fermentation, homemade A2/kefir cheeses, seasonal sauces, flakes, and 50 chapters of flatbread alchemy, grab a copy of The New Mexican Pizza Diet. Let's see what your kitchen comes up with.


The Pizza Podcast defines pizza
The Pizza Podcast defines pizza